🌀 The Screen Turns Around

{{rh_onboarding_line}}

You order an iced latte. The total comes to $6.75. The cashier taps the register twice, swivels the screen toward you, and takes a sudden interest in the pastry case.

Three buttons wait: 20%, 25%, 30%. Under them, in smaller type, sit Custom and No Tip. Making the drink took about forty seconds, and everybody at the counter knows it.

The person behind you in line can see the screen too. Your thumb hovers for two seconds that feel like ten.

You tap 20%, mumble thanks, and walk off mildly annoyed at everyone, yourself included. By the door, you're already drafting the complaint you'll make to a friend later.

Nobody forced you, and nobody said a word. So why did $1.35 feel like a test? And who was grading it?

If you're deciding how much of your budget influencer marketing deserves, start with people who've already made that call.

At the virtual Return on Influence Festival '26 marketing leaders talk about where creators sit in the wider marketing mix, and how to budget for them.

On stage:

It's free, it's online, and you'll take away something you can apply to your job the very next day. (Or the day after. We're not your boss.)

October 21, 2026, 10 am – 5 pm ET.

Save your spot

Athens had the same squirm. In the late 300s BC, the philosopher Theophrastus wrote thirty short sketches of people nobody wants to be. His cheapskate gives himself away fast: "If contributions from the public are asked for, he is silent or rises and quits the company." Spot a friend collecting donations in the street, and he ducks down a side road and takes the long way home.

The ask was a real institution. When the city needed money, it could call for voluntary donations in the Assembly, with fellow citizens looking on. Plutarch tells of the young Alcibiades walking past such a meeting, hearing the applause and going up to give. The crowd shouted so loudly that he forgot the quail tucked in his cloak, and it flew off.

A decree from the 240s BC shows the fine print. Nobody could give less than 50 drachmas or more than 200. Donors would be praised, and their names cut into a stone in the marketplace so their love of honor could be seen by all.

Of the 83 amounts that survive on that stone, 72 are the maximum. The man then running Theophrastus's old school is on it, down for the full 200.

Put those together and the audience was the engine. Being watched paid, in applause and a line in stone. Slip out, and you became a type in a book of bad examples.

A payment made in private is arithmetic. Make the same payment in front of someone and it becomes a statement about the payer. The number stops describing the service, starts describing you.

That's what the buttons are for. The 20, 25 and 30 look like a price list and work like a grading scale: fine, generous, saintly. No Tip is a grade too, and it gets handed out with a witness standing there.

In Athens the witnesses were fellow citizens, people a man would face again at the next meeting, so a good name was worth paying for. The stranger behind you in line can't do a thing for your reputation. The cashier didn't design the screen. Two people stand at the counter acting out a scene neither of them wrote.

The reflex fires anyway. A watched choice still feels like a judged one, even when the judge is busy restocking lids.

It also explains the grumbling. People complain about tipping to pollsters, in private, where candor costs nothing. They tip in public, where it does. Both answers are honest; they come from two different rooms.

The old stage paid its performers, though. Stand up in the Assembly, and the crowd cheered. Tap 30% and you get a receipt.

The complaints are loud. In a March survey of 1,000 consumers by the restaurant-software firm Popmenu, 78% called tipping practices ridiculous and 44% said they're tipping less than last year. Bankrate's 2025 poll found 63% hold at least one negative view of tipping.

The receipts barely notice. Toast, the restaurant payments company, reports the average tip at quick-service counters has sat flat at 15.8% for seven straight quarters. At sit-down restaurants it has hovered between 19.1% and 19.4% for two years.

The screen still has pull: 59% told Popmenu they feel compelled to tip when one asks. Few perform for it, though. Only 7% tap the highest button, while 36% type in a custom amount, the modern way to rise and quit the company.

And where there's no face at all, tips thin out. Popmenu tracks online pickup orders on its own system. In 2022, 78% carried a tip; this year, 62% do.

On the Athenian stone, 72 of 83 surviving donations hit the cap. On the screen, 7% reach for the top button. The stone lists only the willing, so the comparison flatters Athens, but the gap is still wide.

Quote: "The 'what will people say' mania holds the average person in an iron obedience to a custom which is innately loathed." William R. Scott, The Itching Palm (1916).

Study: Across 36,000 real transactions and four experiments, customers who were watched tipped about the same, then were less likely to come back (Warren and Hanson, Journal of Business Research, 2025).

Artifact: The Salvation Army's red kettle. When bell ringers at a Boston supermarket said "please give," about three in ten shoppers switched doors. Theophrastus's cheapskate knew that side road.

What happens to generosity when its audience can only notice the stingy and never honor the giver? And who gains most from a stage where the tipper and the tipped are both just following the screen?

The squirm at the counter is old. An Athenian felt it in the Assembly twenty-three centuries ago, with his fellow citizens waiting to see who'd stand.

What changed is the deal. Athens put givers on a stage and paid them for it, in applause and in stone, and most of the amounts that survive sit at the limit.

The tip screen builds the same stage and pays nothing. Hit the top button, no one claps. Hit the bottom one, someone might notice.

So the tips hold steady while nobody feels generous. The 20% keeps going through, and the irritation keeps going to the pollsters.

We kept the audience and cut the applause.

Send this to the friend who taps 25% on a muffin they picked out themselves, then complains about it the whole walk to the car.

Find yourself in the next one,

Eren.

The Receipts

The artifact

The numbers

The quote, the study and the artifact